Home Design and Development of Maintenance of Certification
One of the hallmarks of National Board Certification is that it is and has always been by teachers, for teachers. With regard to Maintenance of Certification (MOC), National Board has collected and reviewed input from multiple stakeholder groups, including NBCTs, to inform the design of the MOC process. Multiple committees of NBCTs will be involved throughout the development of MOC instructions.
First, a total of five separate surveys and a focus group were conducted with the goals of better understanding:
- our stakeholders, including recently certified NBCTs;
- the professional meaningfulness of the Renewal process to those NBCTs who recently renewed; and
- how Renewal, from assessors’ perspective, could inform the development of MOC.
Establishing what MOC would measure
From there, we began the design. First, we established the construct for MOC, or the knowledge, skills, and attributes from the Standards and Five Core Propositions that it would measure. A group of NBCTs determined that the construct for Renewal’s Profile of Professional Growth (PPG) was still valid and meaningful. Using Renewal’s PPG as their foundation, they identified MOC key concepts and operational parameters. The construct of MOC will remain, in essence, the same as that of the Renewal PPG.
Establishing and evaluating the MOC framework
Next, the NBCT MOC Design Panels performed critical tasks that led to the development of the recommended MOC framework. The construct, or high-level definition of what is being measured, serves as the MOC’s foundation. From the construct other parts of the assessment framework emerged: the specific attributes of the construct, the requirements to be met and evidence to be evaluated. The design panelists’ content expertise and familiarity with Renewal coupled with analysis of multiple data sources including survey findings, focus groups of renewal assessors, and Technical Advisory Group recommendations were an important piece of making sure the MOC framework represented the needs of various stakeholders.
In October 2018, the gathering of input from content experts and stakeholders continued as an Evaluation Committee reviewed the design panels’ work, identified the assessment framework’s strengths and weaknesses, and discussed potential policy implications of MOC. Overall, the MOC Evaluation Committee strongly supported the work of the National Board in its design process. The committee supported the Board’s decision to implement MOC to focus NBCTs’ efforts on providing enriched evidence of and reflection on more recent and relevant professional growth. The committee felt that the National Board’s MOC design process had been thoroughly researched and implemented with the involvement of appropriate stakeholders. All committee members were pleased with the decision to base MOC on a streamlined renewal process, making MOC less expensive and in line with professional growth that could be expected within a five-year time period. In addition, the Technical Advisory Group members observing the Evaluation Committee felt the high degree of agreement among Evaluation Committee members served as an endorsement of the Board’s process and philosophy underpinning the MOC process.
MOC measures an NBCT’s continuing professional growth experiences with a focus on positively impacting student learning. —Board-certified MOC Design Panelists
After reviewing the MOC Design Report, which recounted the process of establishing the framework from start to finish, the National Board’s Certification Council concluded it was confident both in the process used to derive the framework and in the content of the framework itself. The Council found evidence, as did National Board’s Technical Advisory Group, that the Board’s high-level design plan used in establishing the MOC framework was sound and that the appropriate people and constituencies were present in designing and evaluating the MOC framework.
In November 2018, after reading the MOC Design Report, being briefed on the Certification Council’s oversight of the design process, and conducting their own deliberations, the Board of Directors voted unanimously to approve a policy stating the construct of MOC (i.e., high level concept of what is being measured); the outcome of satisfying MOC requirements (i.e., a five-year extension of an NBCT’s certification expiration date); the number of retakes NBCTs are permitted should an NBCT not satisfy MOC requirements; appeals process; and that there would be no restrictions on the number of times an NBCT can extend the expiration date of their certificate via MOC.
Developing the instructions
In March 2019, National Board recruited 18 NBCTs for the MOC Development Content Advisory Committee. These NBCTs comprise the first group of NBCTs to review and provide input on the clarity of the instructions for completing MOC. By fall 2019, a second and independent group of NBCTs will review the instructions while thinking through the MOC process as if they were planning, gathering evidence, and completing the elements of an MOC submission. The reviewers will be able to provide specific revisions and suggestions about the instructions with the goal of identifying areas lacking clarity or details that require greater or less emphasis.
At the end of 2019, NBCTs from all certificate areas were recruited to participate in a pilot of the MOC process. The purpose of the pilot study is to evaluate the clarity of and adjust the MOC instructions prior to opening registration for MOC in September 2020. Participants have been granted an extension for submission of their pilot test materials due to the impact of COVID-19 on instructional circumstances.
- RT @Ebrowndavis: My @LockhartMagnet NB candidates are ready to learn more about @NBPTS rubrics ! Thank you @DrLaTonyaBarnes for the reminde…National BoardAug 10
- Most Teachers Concerned About In-Person School; 2 In 3 Want To Start The Year Online https://t.co/sE3cufwtTG by @NPRNational BoardAug 10
- Many kids struggle with reading – and children of color are far less likely to get the help they need. https://t.co/t1WZchOXgWNational BoardAug 10
- There's still time to join #NBCTstrong @neary_ann for her Zoom panel Black@: A Conversation About Race, Culture & C… https://t.co/P9EQlYr0LiNational BoardAug 10
- RT @CollinsNBCT: Join this amazing team. Help teach a Black curriculum created by black educators for black students! #nbctstrong #ProudCur…National BoardAug 10